Private Practice: Season 4
Episode 16

Title: Love and Lies
Episode: 70
Episode #: 4.16
First Air Date: March 17, 2011 (10pm)
Writer: Moira McMahon
Director: Ann Kindberg
DVD: Private Practice: The Complete Fourth Season
Guest Stars:

Music:

Flo Rida, "Respirator"
Amelia tries to convince Michelle to get tested. Fife is back to woo Naomi.

Trent Dabbs, "Leave To See"
Addison confronts Frank and Isobelle. Charlotte knows that Addison doesn't want to do the surgery. Amelia convinces Michelle that life is worth living. Violet makes a decision. Naomi rejects Sam, Addison, and fife.

William Fitzsimmons, "The Tide Pulls From The Moon"
Naomi rejects Sam, Addison and Fife. Charlotte and Cooper make up. Amelia comforts Addison.


Fan Rating: ??/10 (Average of all fan submitted ratings)


Synopsis:

A woman and her husband want to harvest their unborn baby's eggs; a woman threatens suicide if she tests positive for Huntington's disease; Fife returns to share his feelings with Naomi.

(Preview From ABC)
The doctors of Oceanside clash when an expectant mother and her husband, desperate to have children, come to them in order to harvest the eggs of their unborn, ill-fated baby; meanwhile, Amelia tries to help a friend who threatens suicide if her tests for Huntington's Disease are positive, and Fife returns to tell Naomi how he feels about her.


(Recap From ABC)
Addison is back, as is Dr. Gabriel Fife. First, let’s talk about our favorite, still-grieving neonatal surgeon. She returns to Oceanside in tears, though not over anything specific. Ever since Bizzy’s death, Addy’s been crying a lot. We’re just wondering if the waterworks will continue should she find out that Sam and Naomi kissed. That newsflash will likely trigger tears of fury.

As for Fife, he announces his triumphant return by flooding Naomi’s office with gobs of African Flame lilies. Fife says it’s the national flower of Zimbabwe. He’s right. We checked on Wikipedia. Anyway, Fife is there to woo Naomi away from Oceanside. It won’t be easy once he realizes the object of his affection still has Sam issues. More on that later.

A couple is having a baby with a heart condition that will cause the child to die within a day of her birth. The parents-to-be want Addison to harvest the baby’s eggs so they can be fertilized. They feel it’s the only way they’ll have a chance at parenthood. Charlotte and Addison are considering the morally-suspect procedure. Naomi and Cooper are against it. Nevertheless, Addy makes the call to move forward.

Addison performs an emergency C-section to save the distressed baby. Afterwards, the parents don’t want to see the child. They only want her eggs harvested. Cooper is rocking the baby in the nursery when Addison arrives. His comments about parenting being a lifelong commitment no matter how long or short it may be hit home. Addison brings the baby into the parents where they can’t help but bond with her. Looks like Addison won’t be doing the questionable procedure after all.

Sheldon’s tired of all the ladies in the office coming to him with their problems. He’s become the guy who is not anyone’s boyfriend yet still deals with all the annoying things that boyfriends can’t stand. He’s resigning as everyone’s “not-boyfriend-boyfriend.” He wants Pete and Sam to step up to the plate to deal with their women. They suggest that Sheldon find his own woman or join a monastery. Oh, brother.

Amelia’s friend, Michelle, may or may not have the gene that causes Huntington’s Disease. She refuses to get tested after seeing how the illness destroyed her mother. Amelia persuades her friend to stop living in uncertainty. If the test is negative, Michelle will be taking a big trip to Naples. If it’s positive, she intends to kill herself. That’s precisely why Amelia lies about the results.

Pete tries to persuade Amelia to tell Michelle the truth. Violet suggests she give her friend a reason to live. Amelia lists rocky road ice cream and driving on a sunny day with the top down as just a few of life’s joys. But the real selling point is the promise that Amelia will always be there cheering her on. She’ll also step in once the bad outweighs the good.

Violet is having trouble picking out a photo for her book jacket. She ditches the first set of pics because they are way too sexy. Pete’ll keep a copy for his private files though. The next set of pictures make Violet look like an uptight, stodgy therapist. That’s not who she is. With Pete’s help, Violet snaps a shot revealing the scar that remains from her attack. Of all the photos that were taken, this one’s a keeper.

Addison catches the end of a chat between Sam and Naomi which clues her in that something may have happened. The conversation spirals into one in which Naomi realizes she doesn’t belong at Oceanside anymore. They’ve all crossed so many lines that go against who they are. She just doesn’t feel right there.

Fife offers to take Naomi away with him to Zimbabwe. That won’t work. He’s part of her past. They all are. Naomi walks out the door to an uncertain future. As for Sam and Addison, their future together seems somewhat uncertain now, too.